Rakesh Asthana Calls Sonia Gandhi's Godhra Fire Claim 'Absolutely Wrong', Cites Court Verdicts
Former CBI Special Director Rakesh Asthana has strongly rejected Sonia Gandhi's description of the cause of the 2002 Godhra train fire as disputed in her memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love. Asthana, who was involved in the investigation, said forensic evidence established the cause of the fire and that the findings had been upheld in court. His comments have reignited a political debate over the historical account of the Godhra incident and the subsequent Gujarat riots.
Written by
Banashree Dutta

Rakesh Asthana Rejects Sonia Gandhi's Statement on Godhra Train Fire
Former CBI Special Director Rakesh Asthana has criticised a passage in Congress leader Sonia Gandhi's memoir that describes the cause of the 2002 Godhra train fire as disputed.
Speaking to news agency ANI, Asthana called the statement "absolutely wrong" and maintained that the investigation into the incident had established the cause of the fire through forensic evidence.
Asthana, who was associated with the investigation into the Godhra train burning, said the findings had been tested in court. He also alleged that attempts to question the investigation were politically motivated.
What Sonia Gandhi Wrote in Her Memoir
In her memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, Sonia Gandhi discusses the February 27, 2002, burning of the Sabarmati Express at Godhra in Gujarat.
The train was carrying Hindu kar sevaks returning from Ayodhya when four coaches caught fire, killing 59 people, including women and children.
Gandhi's account describes the incident and its aftermath, stating that the cause of the fire remained disputed. The passage has drawn criticism from Asthana, who argues that the investigation and subsequent judicial proceedings established the circumstances of the incident.
Asthana Says Forensic Evidence Established the Cause
Responding to the memoir's description, Asthana said the investigation was authentic and that its conclusions had been established through the legal process.
He argued that the forensic findings supported the investigation's conclusions and rejected suggestions that the cause of the fire remained unresolved.
Asthana also suggested that continuing to raise doubts about the findings was politically motivated. These remarks represent his response to Gandhi's account and his interpretation of the investigation.
What the Courts Ruled in the Godhra Train Burning Case
The Godhra train burning case went through a lengthy judicial process.
2011: A special court convicted 31 people in connection with the incident.
2014: The Gujarat High Court upheld the convictions of 11 people and acquitted 20 others.
Supreme Court proceedings: The Supreme Court subsequently upheld the Gujarat High Court's verdict, dismissing appeals filed by the convicts.
The judicial proceedings established criminal responsibility for the train burning among those convicted. The court outcomes are central to the debate over Asthana's assertion that the investigation's findings were legally established.
The Godhra Incident and the 2002 Gujarat Riots
The Sabarmati Express was set on fire at Godhra railway station on February 27, 2002. The deaths of 59 passengers were followed by widespread communal violence across Gujarat.
The riots resulted in hundreds of deaths and became one of the most significant and controversial episodes in India's recent political and social history.
The Godhra train burning case and the subsequent Gujarat riots involved separate criminal investigations and judicial proceedings. The convictions in the train burning case should not be confused with findings concerning every incident of violence that followed.
Sonia Gandhi's Memoir Sparks Political Debate
The disagreement over the Godhra passage has added to the political controversy surrounding Sonia Gandhi's memoir.
The book has attracted criticism from BJP leaders over its treatment of several historical and political events. Congress leaders, meanwhile, have defended Gandhi's right to present her personal account.
Asthana's latest comments have brought the Godhra train burning investigation back into public discussion, particularly the distinction between the memoir's description and the findings recorded through the judicial process.
Conclusion
Rakesh Asthana's criticism of Sonia Gandhi's account has renewed debate over the 2002 Godhra train burning. While Asthana maintains that forensic evidence and court proceedings established the cause of the fire, Gandhi's memoir describes it as disputed. The judicial record, including convictions upheld by higher courts, remains an important part of assessing the competing claims.
Keep reading
More in Politics
Politics
Rahul Gandhi Reveals His Parents Fought Only Once During Sonia Gandhi's Memoir Launch
Rahul Gandhi shared a personal memory about his parents, Sonia Gandhi and former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi, during the launch of Sonia Gan…
Politics
'Cheap Personal Attack': TN MP Su Venkatesan Hits Back at Madras High Court Judge, Says He Does Not Own a Car
CPI(M) MP Su Venkatesan has responded to remarks made by Madras High Court Justice G R Swaminathan, who questioned the MP's lifestyle and al…
Politics
Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri Takes Oath as Rajya Sabha Member from Madhya Pradesh
Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri took oath as a re-elected Rajya Sabha member representing Madhya Pradesh on November 17, 2026. Rajya Sabha…
Politics
Rahul Gandhi counters BJP over ‘Mumma on Papa’s lap’ row, shares Lord Shiva-Goddess Parvati photo with message on love and belonging
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has responded to the political controversy surrounding the phrase 'Mumma on Papa's lap' by sharing an image of…
Politics
Delhi Minister Parvesh Verma Announces Public Tours of Arvind Kejriwal's 'Sheesh Mahal' From Next Week
Delhi Public Works Department Minister Parvesh Verma has announced that the former official residence of ex-Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejr…
Politics
Shivakumar Defends Mekedatu Project, Asks Whether Tamil Nadu Parties Have Read Supreme Court Order
Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar has defended the proposed Mekedatu balancing reservoir project across the Cauvery River, quest…
