Business & Economy

Retired RBI Employee Wins ITAT Jaipur Case Over Rs 22.47 Lakh Leave Encashment, Gets Relief From Rs 8.09 Lakh Tax Demand

A retired Reserve Bank of India (RBI) employee has won an income tax appeal at the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Jaipur, over the exemption claimed on Rs 22.47 lakh received as leave encashment. The Income Tax Department had restricted his exemption to Rs 3 lakh and raised a tax demand of Rs 8.09 lakh. In its October 30, 2026 order, the tribunal held that the increased Rs 25 lakh exemption limit should apply retrospectively from January 1, 2016, allowing the employee's full claim.

Share
Retired RBI Employee Wins ITAT Jaipur Case Over Rs 22.47 Lakh Leave Encashment, Gets Relief From Rs 8.09 Lakh Tax Demand

Retired RBI Employee Receives Rs 8.09 Lakh Tax Demand

A retired Reserve Bank of India employee from Jammu, identified as Mr Jain, has received relief from an income tax demand of Rs 8.09 lakh after winning an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Jaipur.

Jain received Rs 22,47,870 as leave encashment when he retired from the RBI during the financial year 2018-19. In his income tax return, he claimed the entire amount as exempt under Section 10(10AA) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Initially, his return was processed with the exemption claim accepted. However, the Assessing Officer subsequently restricted the exemption to Rs 3 lakh and added the remaining Rs 19,47,870 to his salary income.

This increased his assessed total income to Rs 69,86,440 and resulted in a tax demand of Rs 8,09,340. Jain challenged the decision before the tax tribunal. [<Cite refs={["turn758986search0","turn758986search9"]}/>]

ITAT Jaipur Allows Full Exemption on Rs 22.47 Lakh

The ITAT Jaipur heard the appeal on October 30, 2026. The bench comprised Judicial Member T.R. Senthil Kumar and Accountant Member Prakash.

The central issue was whether Jain's leave encashment exemption should be restricted to the earlier Rs 3 lakh ceiling or calculated using the revised Rs 25 lakh limit.

The tribunal ruled in Jain's favour and held that he was entitled to claim exemption on the entire Rs 22,47,870 received as leave encashment.

It set aside the orders restricting the exemption to Rs 3 lakh and directed the Assessing Officer to remove the addition of Rs 19,47,870 from his salary income. The tax demand and interest were also directed to be recomputed accordingly. [<Cite refs={["turn758986search9"]}/>]

Why Did the Tax Department Restrict the Exemption to Rs 3 Lakh?

The dispute arose because the employee retired in the financial year 2018-19, when the exemption limit applicable to non-government employees was still being treated by the tax authorities as Rs 3 lakh.

The Central Government subsequently increased the notified exemption ceiling for leave encashment received at retirement by non-government employees to Rs 25 lakh through a notification dated May 24, 2023.

The notification was made effective from April 1, 2023. The question before the Jaipur tribunal was whether the revised ceiling could also apply to employees who had retired before that date.

Jain argued that the exemption limit should reflect the increase in the corresponding benefit available to government employees. The tribunal accepted this interpretation. [<Cite refs={["turn758986search0","turn758986search9"]}/>]

Why Did ITAT Apply the Rs 25 Lakh Limit Retrospectively?

The tribunal considered the history of changes to the leave encashment exemption limit.

Under Section 10(10AA)(ii), the exemption available to employees other than Central or State Government employees is linked to a limit notified by the Central Government, having regard to the limit applicable to government employees.

The earlier exemption ceiling of Rs 3 lakh had been fixed in 2002. Following the Seventh Pay Commission's revision of the highest government salary to Rs 2.5 lakh per month from January 1, 2016, the corresponding ten-month salary amount became Rs 25 lakh.

The Jaipur bench observed that previous revisions to the exemption ceiling had followed changes in government employees' entitlements. It concluded that the 2023 notification should be applied retrospectively from January 1, 2016, when the corresponding government salary ceiling had increased.

Since Jain retired during 2018-19, after January 1, 2016, the tribunal held that he was eligible for the revised Rs 25 lakh exemption limit. His leave encashment of Rs 22.47 lakh was therefore fully covered. [<Cite refs={["turn758986search0","turn758986search9"]}/>]

How Is Leave Encashment Taxed Under Section 10(10AA)?

Leave encashment is the amount an employee receives for accumulated but unused earned leave. Its tax treatment depends on when the money is received and the employee's category.

For non-government employees, leave encashment received during employment is generally fully taxable as salary. The exemption under Section 10(10AA) applies to qualifying payments received at retirement.

For non-government employees retiring from service, the exempt amount is calculated as the least of the following:

  • The actual leave encashment received.

  • The cash equivalent of unavailed earned leave, subject to a maximum calculation of 30 days for each completed year of service.

  • Ten months' average salary calculated with reference to the ten months immediately preceding retirement.

  • The notified exemption ceiling, currently Rs 25 lakh.

The exemption is subject to the applicable statutory conditions, including adjustment for any exemption already claimed on leave encashment received from previous employers. [<Cite refs={["turn758986search0","turn758986search16"]}/>]

Government Employees and Non-Government Employees: Different Tax Treatment

The Income Tax Act provides different treatment for leave encashment received at retirement.

Central and State Government employees are eligible for full exemption on qualifying leave encashment received at retirement.

For employees of other organisations, including private-sector employers and entities such as the RBI, the exemption is subject to the limits and conditions under Section 10(10AA)(ii).

The RBI employee's case became significant because the Jaipur tribunal examined how the revised exemption ceiling should apply to a retirement that took place before the 2023 notification. [<Cite refs={["turn758986search0","turn758986search16"]}/>]

Is the ITAT Jaipur Ruling the Final Word on Leave Encashment Tax?

The ruling provides relief to Jain, but the broader interpretation of the retrospective application of the Rs 25 lakh exemption limit has faced differing views.

The Economic Times report noted that the Chandigarh bench of the ITAT had taken a contrary position, indicating that the revised ceiling should apply only from April 1, 2023.

The Jaipur bench, however, relied on its interpretation of the statutory provision and the history of earlier revisions. It also observed that where two interpretations are possible, the one favourable to the taxpayer should be adopted.

The legal position may therefore require further consideration by higher judicial forums. The Jaipur order should not automatically be treated as a final nationwide resolution of every similar case. [<Cite refs={["turn758986search0","turn758986search9"]}/>]

What Retired Employees Should Know

The case highlights the importance of checking the applicable exemption limit when filing an income tax return involving retirement benefits.

Retired employees who received leave encashment before April 1, 2023, may want to examine the relevant assessment year, retirement date, amount received and applicable legal position before considering any claim.

However, the ITAT Jaipur ruling does not mean that every employee who received leave encashment before 2023 will automatically qualify for a refund. Individual claims depend on the facts, statutory conditions, procedural rules and the legal position applicable to the taxpayer.

Enjoyed this story? Share it.

Share

Keep reading

More in Business & Economy

View all
Senior Citizen FD Rates Up to 8.60% for Five Years: Check the List of Small Finance Banks
Breaking

Business & Economy

Senior Citizen FD Rates Up to 8.60% for Five Years: Check the List of Small Finance Banks

Senior citizens aged 60 years and above can earn fixed deposit interest of up to 8.60% per annum on a five-year deposit from Suryoday Small…

5 min read
EPF Systematic Withdrawal Plan: Will Monthly Retirement Withdrawals Be Tax-Free? Experts Explain
Breaking

Business & Economy

EPF Systematic Withdrawal Plan: Will Monthly Retirement Withdrawals Be Tax-Free? Experts Explain

The Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) has approved a proposal to introduce a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP), allowing retiring…

7 min read
NRE FD Interest Rates in November 2026: PNB, Kotak and Federal Bank Offer Up to 6.80%
Breaking

Business & Economy

NRE FD Interest Rates in November 2026: PNB, Kotak and Federal Bank Offer Up to 6.80%

Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) can earn up to 6.80% interest on Non-Resident External (NRE) fixed deposits in November 2026. Punjab National Ba…

5 min read
Can Self-Acquired Property Become Joint Family Property? Why the Owner's Intention Matters
Breaking

Business & Economy

Can Self-Acquired Property Become Joint Family Property? Why the Owner's Intention Matters

A self-acquired property can become joint family or Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) property under certain circumstances. The owner's clear int…

6 min read
Failed to Disclose Foreign Bank Account in ITR? CBDT Explains How to Get Tax Amnesty Under FAST-DS 2026
Breaking

Business & Economy

Failed to Disclose Foreign Bank Account in ITR? CBDT Explains How to Get Tax Amnesty Under FAST-DS 2026

The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has issued supplementary FAQs explaining how taxpayers can disclose foreign bank accounts and other…

9 min read
EPF SWP for Lifelong Monthly Income: How a ₹50 Lakh Retirement Corpus Can Generate Regular Payouts
Breaking

Business & Economy

EPF SWP for Lifelong Monthly Income: How a ₹50 Lakh Retirement Corpus Can Generate Regular Payouts

The Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) has approved a proposal to introduce a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP), allowing retiring…

6 min read